​​​​​

Require Adequate Corrosion Testing and Qualification of Long-Term Fire Retardants Used in Aerial Firefighting

What Happened

The National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) is providing the following information to urge the United States Department of Agriculture Forest Service (USFS) to act on safety recommendations in t​his report. These recommendations address inadequate corrosion testing and qualification requirements for long-term fire retardants (LTFRs) used in aerial firefighting. The USFS’s testing specifications and qualification process for LTFRs allowed a product with a novel LTFR chemistry to receive full qualification for use by large airtankers without adequate evaluation of its potential corrosive effects on aircraft materials and structures under representative operating conditions, including effects associated with the comingling of LTFRs based on fundamentally different chemistries. Corrosion associated with such comingling could compromise the continued airworthiness and safe operation of large airtankers.​​​

What We Found

​​We identified these safety issues during our investigation, conducted at the USFS’s request, of an incident involving significant corrosion discovered on two large airtankers under contract to the USFS that had carried and dispensed a new LTFR during operational trial in the 2023 fire season to determine product suitability during field use. The NTSB determined that the probable cause of this incident was the use of a new LTFR with a chemical composition incompatible with the retardant previously in use for the integration-operational field evaluation without adequate testing and qualification. The NTSB is issuing two safety recommendations to the USFS.

What We Recommend

​​As a result of this investigation, we made the following new safety recommendations.

To the United States Forest Service:

  1. Work with aircraft corrosion experts from industry and government, airtanker operators, and retardant manufacturers to develop robust corrosion test procedures that address the range of materials typically used in aircraft construction, built-up structures incorporating those materials, galvanic coupling, retardant comingling, and possible chemical interaction effects. (A-26-66)
  2. Revise the requirements for long-term fire retardant qualification contained in Specification 5100-304d, Long-Term Retardant, Wildland Firefighting, to incorporate the procedures developed in response to Safety Recommendation A-26-66. (A-26-67)

​​​​​​ ​
​
​