Good morning and welcome to the National Transportation Safety Board. I’m Jennifer Homendy and I’m honored to serve as Chair of the NTSB.
With me today are my Board colleagues: Member Michael Graham, Member Tom Chapman, Member Alvin Brown, and Member Todd Inman.
Today’s meeting is open to the public, in accordance with the Government in the Sunshine Act.
We’re here to discuss the final investigation report of a natural gas–fueled explosion and fire that occurred on March 24, 2023, at the R.M. Palmer Company, a candy manufacturer, in West Reading, Pennsylvania.
The explosion destroyed one of the factory’s buildings and caused significant structural damage another, as well as surrounding structures, including an apartment building.
Seven people were killed, all of whom were Palmer employees; ten others were injured, including seven Palmer employees and three bystanders, who assisted the injured after the explosion.
Three families were displaced from the neighboring apartment building.
I’d like to take a moment to address those personally affected by this tragedy. On behalf of the entire agency, please accept our heartfelt sympathies for all you’ve been through.
Please know that our work does not end with the issuance of our final investigation report. After today’s proceedings we will work diligently to implement our safety recommendations, no matter how long that takes.
Let’s now turn to today’s meeting.
Each Board Member has studied the draft report and met individually with the investigative team, but this is the first time we’ve gathered as a Board to discuss the report.
In a moment, NTSB staff will present the pertinent facts and analysis and summarize their findings in detail.
After their presentations, Board Members will examine the key safety issues uncovered during the investigation. These include:
- Natural Gas Migration and Pipe Damage.
- Integrity Management, Operations, and Pennsylvania One Call.
- Emergency Response and Valve Accessibility.
- Public Awareness.
Staff will then propose the relevant findings, probable cause, and safety recommendations for Board consideration.
Following the incorporation of any amendments voted on today, the final report will be available on our website in a few weeks.
The public docket for this investigation was released on February 22, 2024, and contains over 2,700 pages of additional relevant material. It’s available on our website at NTSB.gov.
As we know all-too-well, emergency responders are key to significantly reducing injuries, minimizing property damage, and facilitating a quicker recovery by enabling prompt action and coordinated efforts during critical moments of a crisis, potentially saving lives and protecting communities when disasters occur.
Proper planning and response can be the difference between life and death in emergency situations.
A total of 30 fire and rescue companies, 15 law enforcement agencies, 9 emergency medical services, and 2 local urban search and rescue companies responded to this tragedy.
I want to thank the dedicated professionals from each of those organizations.
Before I turn it over to Mr. Curtis, I’d like to acknowledge the Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration and its more than 500 dedicated employees.
In addition to serving as a party to this investigation, PHMSA is celebrating its 20th anniversary as an agency.
PHMSA was created in the Norman Y. Mineta Research and Special Programs Improvement Act of 2004, the first Public Law that I worked on as Staff Director of the Subcommittee on Railroads, Pipelines, and Hazardous Materials for the Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure.
The law made clear that, in carrying out its duties, PHMSA must consider the assignment and maintenance of safety as its highest priority, recognizing the clear intent, encouragement, and dedication of Congress to the furtherance of the highest degree of safety in pipeline transportation and hazardous materials transportation.
Safety as the highest priority.
PHMSA and NTSB have pursued that goal together over the last two decades, which have seen remarkable safety improvements:
- The creation of 811.
- The National Pipeline Mapping System.
- Operator Qualification.
- Hazardous Liquid Integrity Management.
- Gas Transmission Integrity Management.
- Gas Distribution Integrity Management.
- Excess flow valves.
- Automatic and remote-controlled shut-off valves in new pipelines.
- Control room management.
- Integrity Verification.
- Gas gathering lines.
- Hydrogen pipelines, methane leak detection...I could go on.
Thank you to Deputy Administrator Brown and the entire PHMSA team for two decades of safety leadership. As the events of West Reading demonstrate, the nation needs you more than ever.
I’ll now ask Deputy Managing Director for Investigations Brian Curtis to introduce members of the NTSB team participating in today’s meeting. Good morning, Mr. Curtis.