Opening Statement - On the Investigation into Box Truck Centerline Crossover Collision with Bus

​​​Good morning and welcome to the National Transportation Safety Board. I’m Jennifer Homendy and I’m honored to serve as Chair of the NTSB.

With me today are my Board colleagues: Member Michael Graham, Member Tom Chapman, Member Alvin Brown, and Member Todd Inman.​​

Today’s meeting is open to the public, in accordance with the Government in the Sunshine Act.

We’re here to discuss the final investigation report of a fatal crash that occurred on January 28, 2023, on Route 37 in Louisville, New York.

At about 6:00 a.m., a 2013 medium-sized Chevrolet Express bus operated by LBFNY was traveling west on Route 37. The bus was transporting 14 migrant workers to a solar farm construction site in Ogdensburg, New York.

At the same time, a 2021 Freightliner box truck operated by Aero Global Logistics, or AGL, was traveling east on Route 37.

As the two vehicles approached each other, the truck crossed over Route 37’s centerline and collided with the driver’s side of the bus nearly head-on.

As a result, six bus passengers died in the crash, two were seriously injured, five received minor injuries, and one was uninjured. The bus driver sustained minor injuries.

The truck driver, who was the only occupant in that vehicle, was seriously injured.

I’d like to take a moment to address those personally affected by this tragedy. On behalf of the entire agency, please accept our heartfelt condolences for all you’ve been through. We are truly sorry for your pain, whether you lost a loved one in this crash or were injured in any way.

Please know that our work does not end with the issuance of a final investigation report. After today’s proceedings we will work diligently to implement our safety recommendations, no matter how long that takes.

This past Sunday was World Day of Remembrance for Road Traffic Victims.

It was a time for communities throughout North America, South America, Europe, Asia, Africa, Australia, and Oceania to come together to honor those who’ve died or been injured by traffic violence. It was also a time to demand action to save lives on our nation’s roads.

Thank you to the NTSB staff who participated in the bike ride that retraced the route that mother and U.S. diplomat Sarah Langenkamp took in Bethesda the day she died riding her bike in 2022. I and several other staff participated in the walk from Freedom Plaza to the Lincoln Memorial, where a rally was held.

There is no doubt: we are in the midst of a growing public health crisis on our roads.

According to the World Health Organization, 1.19 million people around the world die annually in roadway crashes.

That’s 3,261 people every single day; 136 every hour; three every minute.

By the time I finish this sentence in 20 seconds, one person somewhere around the world will have died in a roadway crash.

It doesn’t have to be this way.

Unlike most developed nations, U.S. roadways have grown more deadly over the last several decades.

Last year, 2.7 million people were injured and 40,990 people died on our roads. That’s 112 people every single day.

The victims of the Louisville crash are among them.

In my lifetime alone, 2.2 million people have died on our roads.

By raw numbers, the U.S. has more motor-vehicle deaths than any other developed country. We also have the highest death rate.

At the NTSB, we believe the only acceptable number of injuries and crashes on our roads is zero. Zero.

Plenty of people think zero deaths is an unrealistic goal; some call it a “pipedream.” 

It’s not. Many villages, towns, and cities around the world are having incredible success saving lives on their roads, including here in the United States.

They all have one thing in common: they embrace the Safe System Approach to traffic safety.

In this model, a “safe” road system is one that builds in many layers of redundancy so that if one layer fails, people are still protected.

Places that have successfully eliminated traffic deaths also understand that everyone...every part of society...shares the responsibility for safety. By holding everyone — and I mean everyone — accountable for doing their part, zero is possible.

Over the course of this meeting, you’ll likely hear about how the entire system failed the victims of the Louisville crash...how there was insufficient redundancy to protect the people traveling on Route 37 that morning.

That’s why we’ll talk in depth about the responsibilities of everyone involved, not just the individual drivers.

This includes both motor carriers and the regulator, the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA); the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, which regulates vehicle design and performance standards; and the states of New York and Montana; among others.

It will soon become clear to those listening that each of these entities could have...should have...done more to prevent this horrific crash.

The NTSB believes every roadway crash is preventable. This crash is no different. What is different is that FMSCA’s inadequate oversight played an outsized role.

I say that because we don’t just have a deadly crash between two motor carriers — we have a deadly crash between two motor carriers that were known to be unsafe.

And yet, a truly safe system anticipates risk and builds in redundancy to eliminate that risk.

That’s why we have the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration. It’s their role...their duty...to act as a safety stopgap.

FMCSA was created in the Motor Carrier Safety Improvement Act of 1999, which opens by stating the following: “The current rate, number, and severity of crashes involving motor carriers in the United States are unacceptable.”

At the time, we were losing about 5,400 people annually in commercial truck-related crashes. That same year, then-Transportation Secretary Rodney Slater set an ambitious goal: reducing commercial truck-related fatalities by half over the next decade, to about 2,700 deaths.

We’ve never even come close to achieving Secretary Slater’s goal.

The best year was 2009, when 3,380 people died in crashes involving large trucks.

And today? We’re losing nearly 6,000 people a year in these crashes.

We’re moving in the wrong direction.

The law establishing FMCSA goes on to say: “In carrying out its duties, the Administration shall consider the assignment and maintenance of safety as the highest priority.”

Safety as the highest priority.

To live up to that ideal, FMCSA must be able to identify and take action against motor carriers that are unfit for service — especially carriers that are actively working to mask their history of crashes and noncompliance with regulations and avoid safety oversight, like the ones involved in this crash.

FMCSA must have in place strong regulations to protect public safety and then take action to enforce those regulations.

And, when necessary, FMCSA must act swiftly to remove dangerous carriers from our roads.

Yes, we absolutely need motor carriers to do their part, but we need to strengthen every layer of the system.

That starts and ends with FMCSA. Why?

Because, when it comes to preventing mass-casualty events involving unsafe motor carriers — like the Louisville tragedy — FMCSA is the first and last line of defense when it comes to public safety.

Let’s now turn to today’s meeting.

Each Board Member has studied the draft report and met individually with the investigative team, but this is the first time we’ve gathered as a Board to discuss the report.

In a moment, NTSB staff will present the pertinent facts and analysis and summarize their findings in detail.

After their presentations, Board Members will question staff on the key safety issues uncovered during the investigation. These include:

  • Crash discussion and occupant protection.
  • Safety practices for managing fatigue and crash risk.
  • Federal oversight of motor carrier operations.

Staff will then propose the relevant findings, probable cause, and safety recommendations for Board consideration.

Following the incorporation of any amendments voted on today, the final report will be available on our website in a few weeks.

The public docket for this investigation was released on January 31, 2024, and contains over 2,000 pages of additional relevant material. It’s available on our website at NTSB.gov.

Before I turn it over to staff, some “thank-yous.”

Post-crash care is an essential component of the Safe System Approach, which is why some appropriately refer to it as “the last best chance to save a life.”

To that end, I’d like to thank the dedicated professionals from 17 state and local agencies who responded to the Louisville crash scene:

  • New York State Police, who also served as a party to our investigation.
  • Louisville Volunteer Fire Department.
  • Massena Rescue.
  • Massena Volunteer Fire Department.
  • Waddington Rescue.
  • Waddington Volunteer Fire Department.
  • Madrid Rescue.
  • Madrid Volunteer Fire Department.
  • St. Lawrence County Sheriff’s Office.
  • Norfolk Volunteer Fire Department.
  • Norfolk Rescue.
  • Canton Rescue.
  • Ogdensburg Rescue.
  • St. Lawrence County Emergency Services.
  • Seaway Valley Rescue.
  • Potsdam Rescue.
  • And the St. Lawrence County Coroner’s Office.

On behalf of the NTSB, thank you, all.

I’ll now ask Deputy Managing Director for Investigations Brian Curtis to introduce members of the NTSB team participating in today’s meeting.

Good morning, Mr. Curtis.


​​​​​​ ​
​
​