Remarks as prepared for delivery.
Thank you, Mark, for that warm welcome.
Few things could keep me away from the New York Auto Show. In fact, it was the first thing I put on my 2026 calendar. I’ve been looking forward to it all year.
What I did not expect was that the NTSB’s mission would bring me to New York last week.
On March 22nd, Jazz Aviation, Air Canada Express Flight 8646 — a CRJ 900 — collided with a fire truck on Runway 4 at LaGuardia Airport. Both pilots were killed in the collision; dozens more were injured — some seriously so. Our hearts are with the pilots’ families and every person injured in the accident.
The NTSB is leading the safety investigation into this tragedy. Our investigators remained on scene until earlier this week. We’ll issue a preliminary report within 30 days.
Our mission is the same for every accident, crash, and incident we investigate: To determine exactly how it happened, why it happened, and, most importantly, what’s needed to prevent it from ever happening again.
While our agency is best known for our aviation investigations, that’s not where the greatest need is.
Our aviation system, though consistently stressed in new and challenging ways, is generally safe. Nearly 3 million passengers fly without incident every day in and out of U.S. airports. Commercial aviation is the safest way to travel by far.
The National Airspace System is much safer than the National Highway System — or any U.S. road, for that matter, where 95% of transportation deaths occur.
That translates to about 110 people dying every single day; three of them are from New York State. About five people die in the U.S. every hour from a traffic crash.
Two people will die by the time I finish these remarks.
That is chilling. I say that as a mother. I pray every day for the safety of my daughter, Lexi, who’s a relatively new driver.
We shouldn’t need prayer. What we need is action.
Action on NTSB’s safety recommendations, too many of which are years … even decades … old.
Action, not just for the 110 people dying every single day, but for the MILLIONS who are physically injured in road crashes every year. I say “physical” because the trauma that occurs from any crash can be life long.
I know this from my own experience of being rear-ended at high speed while stationary at a red light in 2021. My Subaru saved my life.
I know that’s a somber start for such an exciting event — a day where we’re here to celebrate “safety and mobility” and revel in all that’s new on four wheels.
I swear, I get mesmerized looking into the glossy paint shining under the lights on the showroom floor … I love to marvel at the feats of engineering they represent — the power and the beauty; a perfect marriage of form meeting function.
It’s why we’re here: To get a glimpse into the future of mobility.
It is so much fun to focus on what’s next … the newest bells and whistles … the concept cars, innovative designs and features for the next model year.
To the automakers here: You are doing amazing things. Breathtaking things. You excel at pushing the boundaries of what’s possible … dreaming big … “wow-ing” auto enthusiasts the world over — starting with me!
So my message this morning may surprise you:
We can’t forget the basics.
We must implement the technology we have right here, right now, to save lives:
- Forward collision warning and automatic emergency braking (AEB). I applaud automakers for embracing AEB, voluntarily making it a standard feature on virtually all new cars.
- We also support AEB systems that protect pedestrians, bicyclists, and motorcyclists…
- In-vehicle alcohol detection…
- Advanced speed limiting technologies…
- Driver monitoring systems, and more.
I’ll be the first to admit it: Talking about safety tech isn’t “sexy” or glamorous. Frankly, it’s not as much fun as talking about artificial intelligence-powered voice assistants … biometric vehicle access … head-up displays with augmented reality; I could go on.
Until every new car is equipped with proven safety technologies, we’re leaving lives on the table.
And that is unacceptable.
The technology exists today to prevent every traffic death caused by the three biggest contributors to death on our roads.
- That’s over 12,000 fatal crashes from impaired driving annually;
- 11,000 from speeding; and
- Over 3,000 from distraction — a number that’s likely a huge underestimate.
We know these behaviors often go together. A perfect example is the Board meeting we held earlier this week, where we considered the final investigation report into two fatal, rear-end collisions. In both cases, a 2022 Ford Mustang Mach-E operating in hands-free partial driving automation mode, called BlueCruise.
The first crash occurred on February 24, 2024, in San Antonio, Texas, where the Ford driver rear-ended a stationary Honda CR-V in the center lane of eastbound Interstate 10.
The second crash occurred eight days later, on March 3, 2024, in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. The Ford driver rear-ended a stationary Hyundai Elantra in the left lane of northbound Interstate 95, triggering a sequence of crashes involving two other vehicles.
Tragically, in these two crashes combined, three people died and two people sustained minor physical injuries.
Impairment, speeding, and distraction each played a role in these tragedies.
Let’s start with impairment.
In Philly, the driver was impaired by alcohol — the effects of which may have been worsened by her marijuana use.
San Antonio: the CR-V whose driver was killed was stopped in the center lane of Interstate 10, creating an unexpected hazard. Why? It may have been because the driver was impaired.
The NTSB has issued about 150 safety recommendations addressing impaired driving since 1968.
There are technology solutions in development and available on the market now that can eliminate drunk driving once and for all ... systems that we’ve recommended for years.
In the Infrastructure law, Congress mandated that the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) issue a final rule requiring advanced impaired driving technology in all new passenger vehicles. The deadline? November 2024.
We’re still waiting. We can’t afford to wait any longer.
Thirty-seven people are dying every single day our roads because of drunk driving ... 37 people today ... 37 more tomorrow ... and 37 more the day after that.
Which is why, on Tuesday, the Board issued a finding stating that NHTSA’s failure to meet the deadline “continues to expose the public to dangers posed by impaired drivers.”
We also reiterated our call for NHTSA require all new vehicles to be equipped with passive alcohol-impairment detection systems or advanced driver monitoring systems, or both, to prevent drunk driving.
To its credit, Ford did equip the Mach-E with a driver monitoring system, even though it’s not required. But their systems aren’t designed to detect impairment or drowsiness — just distraction, which I’ll come back to.
Speeding.
The driver in the Philly crash was going about 27 mph over the speed limit in a work zone. Had she been traveling at the posted speed limit of 45 mph, the forward collision warning and automatic emergency braking systems would have been more likely to alert the driver sooner or mitigate the crash.
This isn’t just a driver problem, but a systems issue.
Ford allows drivers to disable automatic emergency braking, set their cruise speed 20 mph above the posted speed limit, and operate in hands-free partial automation mode in work zones.
And then there’s distraction, which the Board cited in the probable causes of both BlueCruise crashes.
Specifically, their distraction was due to overreliance on the vehicle’s hands-free partial automation system and disengagement from the driving task.
Because they were distracted, both drivers failed to avoid collision.
Because they were distracted, both drivers rear-ended stationary vehicles at highway speeds. As you heard, the consequences were deadly.
I often hear from manufacturers that automation in vehicles is the solution to what is clearly a public health crisis on our roads. I think they need to be very careful with these claims.
I support myriad safety technologies; after all, “safer vehicles” is part of a Safe System Approach, which the NTSB has endorsed.
My Subaru is an SAE Level 2, partially automated vehicle, I often use its “EyeSight” adaptive cruise control.
But I steer clear of lane-centering because I know the evidence.
Decades of research across various industries, including aviation, concludes that humans are poorly suited for automation monitoring tasks and susceptible to complacency.
A 2001 study revealed that air traffic controllers are less effective at detecting conflicts between aircraft when they assume a passive, monitoring role, as compared to actively controlling the airspace. The effect is even more pronounced under high traffic loads.
In 2024, the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) demonstrated that the presence of partial automation systems didn’t result in lower crash rates.
Their conclusion? These systems function primarily as convenience features rather than safety enhancements.
That same year (2024), a joint study by IIHS and the Center for Transportation and Logistics at MIT studied how drivers adapt to partial automation safeguards over time.
The results are extremely concerning: Drivers adjust, learning to internalize safeguard sequences and find windows of opportunity to do non-driving-related activities.
And numerous studies have found that, when operating a vehicle partial automation mode, drivers are MORE likely to engage in non-driving-related activities than if they were manually driving.
Certainly, I look forward to the day when we can say we’ve eliminated impaired driving, speeding, and distraction. And I’m hopeful in-vehicle technologies can help make that a reality.
But we have a long way to go.
Next month will mark the 10-year anniversary of the first fatal partial automation crash in the U.S., which occurred in Williston, Florida.
The NTSB has been concerned about the safe implementation of these systems ever since.
More tragedies were to follow:
- January 2018; Culver City, California.
- March 2018; Mountainview, California, where one person died and another was injured.
- March 2019; Delray Beach, Florida, where one person died in a sequence that closely resembles the Williston crash.
Overreliance on automation, which can lead to complacency, played a role in all these tragedies.
Each one is a painful reminder that insufficient federal oversight is leading to catastrophic outcomes.
In a perfect world, NHTSA would set minimum performance standards for safety technologies, test them, rate them, and put that information somewhere all auto-buyers will find it: On the car window sticker.
Just like crashworthiness ratings. Just like the rest of the world does.
But the U.S. government doesn’t do this. Automakers are left to create and test to their own standards.
In the year 2026, it’s simply unacceptable that a car in the U.S. can achieve a five-star safety rating even if it has ZERO collision-prevention and other driver assistance technologies.
Our European counterparts are setting standards on what safety technologies must be on vehicles and how they must perform and issuing regulations to prevent unintended consequences from mandating such technologies; they are certainly well ahead of us when it comes to safety ratings.
Thankfully, organizations like IIHS and Consumer Reports have stepped up to fill the void. Their tests reveal that not all manufacturers’ safety technologies are created equal; some perform better than others … most don’t work as intended 100% of the time.
And many U.S. consumers — if not most — are completely unaware.
Case in point: The Mach-E driver monitoring system, which didn’t recognize distraction in either crash:
- In San Antonio, the driver was glancing at the road often enough to reset the distraction alert timer. But he wasn’t actually focused on the road; his final glance ahead was just 0.2 seconds — not enough time to detect the CR-V and steer out of its path.
- In Philly, the driver was looking at an object, likely her cell phone, that she was holding on top of the steering wheel. The problem? That’s a blind spot for the driver monitoring system camera. The system incorrectly determined she was paying attention to the road because she was looking forward; in reality, she was distracted by something else in her line of sight.
Again, I applaud Ford for having a driver monitoring system even though they’re not required to … even though the regulator has been “asleep at the wheel” when it comes to acting on our longstanding recommendation to develop performance standards.
On Tuesday, we superseded that recommendation, essentially strengthening it. We’ve called on NHTSA to: “Require that all new SAE International Level 2-capable passenger vehicles be equipped with driver monitoring systems capable of minimizing driver disengagement, automation complacency, and misuse of vehicle automation […]”
At a minimum, this means addressing the performance gaps revealed by our investigation — like differentiating genuine on-road glances from attention directed to objects, such as cell phones, located in the driver’s forward line of sight, among others.
People buy 16 million new cars or light duty trucks in the U.S. each year.
That’s 16 million chances to save a life.
Some of those sales will take place here, at the New York International Auto Show. Many more will be influenced by this event: Over 80% of attendees say the Show influences their next vehicle purchase.
Which is why I’m so grateful you’re putting safety front and center.
We KNOW how to save lives on our roads through safer vehicles.
Safety is a shared responsibility. We must do this together. Regulators. Lawmakers and states. Manufacturers. Road designers and engineers. All road users.
We must keep fighting. Together.
We must fight for all those who are no longer here to fight for themselves … for the families of 40,000 victims who lose a loved one on our roads each year.
It’s an honor to fight alongside each of you.
Thank you for your commitment to saving lives … to advancing the future of “safety and mobility.”
I look forward to our discussion.