The TWA Flight 514 50th Anniversary Remembrance Ceremony

​As prepared for delivery

Thank you, Peter. And thank you to the Bluemont Citizens Association for hosting this meaningful event: the first-ever ceremony honoring the 92 lives lost onboard Trans World Airlines Flight 514.

Hassan: Thank you for your safety leadership. You and the Flight Safety Foundation are vital partners to the NTSB. 

And I want to be sure to recognize the Seeberger family for their efforts in making today possible.

Together with the planning committee, Lisa and Scott were able to contact relatives for so many of those who perished in this tragedy.

I hear they were aided in no small part by the online research skills of their daughter, Sarah. 

I’d like to start by addressing the families here today. 

I am so sorry for your loss. I say that on behalf of everyone at the National Transportation Safety Board. 

I imagine that it’s not easy to be here. Even five decades later. 

Those who have lost loved ones know that time doesn’t really heal all wounds... we can only learn to live with the grief and perhaps turn that grief into action to bring about meaningful safety change.

I recognize that nothing…no memorial, no plaque, no remembrance ceremony…can give you what you deserve: To have your loved ones back with you. 

Events like this remind us what really matters, why our work at the NTSB is so vital — why we fight so hard to improve transportation safety.

Because people died...and they are still dying. 

Real people — not numbers: Mothers, fathers, sons, daughters, grandparents, aunts, uncles, cousins, colleagues, friends, and neighbors.

People who weren’t with us for Thanksgiving. 

People who weren’t here for other holidays, for our biggest achievements and celebrations in life: Hanukkah, Christmas, New Year’s, Valentine’s Day, Easter, graduations, weddings, birthdays.

Today, we remember them all. We honor them all.

Today, we also reaffirm our commitment to aviation safety.

Today, we renew our promise to vigorously work to prevent similar suffering for other families. 

If you’re not familiar with the NTSB, we’re a small but mighty Federal agency of about 440 dedicated safety professionals. 

One of them is here with me today: Tim LeBaron, Director of the Office of Aviation Safety. 

We investigate aviation accidents and incidents. We also investigate train derailments and collisions. Marine accidents. Motor vehicle crashes. Pipeline ruptures. Commercial space mishaps. 

Our investigators were here five decades ago. 

Maybe you were one of the kind people who cooked for them, baked for them. They, like you, remember that day.

Our role is the same following every accident we investigate: To determine exactly what happened, why it happened and, most importantly, how to prevent it from ever happening again. 

Maybe you saw the NTSB team on-scene following the crash. 

One of their first tasks was to search for the cockpit voice recorder and flight data recorder — the so-called “black boxes.” 

Thankfully for aviation safety, NTSB investigators were able to locate them. 

Back at our labs in D.C., our teams got the information we needed to determine what happened. 

This is from a recent news article, talking about the recorders from Flight 514: “The data investigators found on them resonated throughout the global airline industry and in the halls of Congress.”

I agree wholeheartedly, but with one tweak: The data itself didn’t change anything. But the safety recommendations we made based on that data...and all the evidence we collected...did forever change aviation. 

“From tragedy we draw knowledge to improve the safety of us all.” That was etched in glass outside our former training center. 

From tragedy we draw knowledge to improve the safety of us all.

The knowledge we drew from this tragedy has, without a doubt, made all of us safer. 

That means every person who sets foot on a commercial flight anywhere in the world. 

That also includes all of us living, working, and playing here at ground level.

Improvements like standardizing communications between pilots and air traffic controllers. 

This was a major issue uncovered by our investigation. 

Our report stated: “Neither the pilot nor the controller understood what the other was thinking or planning.” 

We also found that this was a known problem for a long time. This is from our report, and I quote: 

Both military and civil aviation officials for several years had indicated concern [...] about the possibility of misunderstandings which could result in pilots descending prematurely.

Heartbreakingly, that’s exactly what happened. 

Our investigation also revealed that a United Airlines flight, flying the same approach, had a near-miss event similar to TWA 514 just weeks before the tragedy. 

Had that information been more widely distributed, the flight crew of TWA 514 might not have crashed. 

As a result, the FAA created a confidential reporting system that is still in use today and has saved countless lives. 

It’s a place where all aviation industry workers can report safety concerns without fear of retaliation, called the Aviation Safety Reporting System. 

The purpose is to identify safety issues early and then mitigate them before an accident occurs and, as Flight 514 taught us, to ensure vital safety information gets to everyone who needs it. 

One more. 

The aircraft flying as TWA 514 — a Boeing 727 — didn’t have technology to alert the crew they were flying too close to terrain until it was too late.

Flight 514 is the reason large commercial airplanes today must be equipped with ground proximity warning systems — technology that warns pilots of terrain with enough time to take corrective action. 

I could go on. 

These transformational safety improvements and many others have contributed to a remarkable achievement — one you heard from Dr. Shahidi: A record level of aviation safety. 

U.S. aviation is the envy of the world; other nations look to us as the “gold standard” for safety. 

Commercial aviation is now the safest way to travel, period.

And that’s all because we draw knowledge...learn from tragedies like Flight 514. 

Now, the NTSB can’t mandate change. Our recommendations are voluntary.

Fortunately, the Federal Administration Administratoino (FAA) made some significant changes informed by our findings in real time; we didn’t even have to issue recommendations in some areas, which is fantastic.

But not all our recommendations were heeded. 

That happens more often than we’d like. 

Sometimes there is progress, but it takes years...other times, decades...to make safety change, which is unacceptable. 

There’s a question I’m often asked: “What keeps you up at night?” 

The answer is always the same: It’s the next family I‘ll meet who’s lost a loved one in a preventable tragedy. 

And it’s the conversations I have with our investigators on scene about how that tragedy could have…should have…been prevented had one of our safety recommendations been implemented. 

It’s heartbreaking. 

Because these deaths are preventable…were preventable.

The NTSB believes that the only acceptable number of lives lost in transportation accidents is zero. 

That’s why we fight so hard for change. Why we advocate for our recommendations. Why we don’t rest until they’re implemented. 

Because NTSB recommendations are simply words on a page if no one heeds their warning.

You deserve better. 

You deserve action. 

Your family members and friends who passed away 50 years ago today certainly deserve a memorial service, yes.

But they deserve more.

They deserve for us to continue to learn from what happened that day, so it never, ever happens again. 

From tragedy we draw knowledge to improve the safety of us all.

The NTSB has nearly 300 aviation safety recommendations that have never been acted upon.

Hundreds of safety recommendations that came at far too high a cost: Lives lost.

Hundreds of tangible safety improvements that could have prevented tragedies and injuries and saved lives. 

That could save lives today…tomorrow. 

But only if they’re implemented. 

Which means we have more work to do…a lot more work to do…to get to zero. 

Zero at sea and on our waterways.

Zero on passenger rail and freight rail.

Zero on our transit systems.

Zero on our streets and sidewalks.

Zero in our bike lanes and bus lanes.

Zero along every inch of pipeline running under your feet and mine.

Zero in our skies and in our airspace.

Zero under the stars of outer space. 

Today reminds us of the progress we’ve made, but also how much farther we have to go. 

Today, we renew our call for action.

For the 92 lives lost on TWA Flight 514.

For the lives we can still save.

Thank you.

                                                          ​​


​​​​​​ ​
​
​