Remarks to the Transportation Improvement Association Annual Meeting and First Responder Appreciation Breakfast

​​​​Remarks as prepared for delivery​

Good morning! Thank you, Secretary Edevbie, for that warm welcome. I also want to thank Jim and all the other speakers for your safety leadership.

It’s an honor to be here this morning to help show appreciation for Michigan’s first responders. 

The NTSB couldn’t do what we do without the police, fire fighters, paramedics, dispatchers, hazmat specialists, and so many others who heed the call when tragedy occurs. 

Your partnership with us on scene during our investigations and in the days, weeks, and months that follow is critical. 

If you’re not familiar with the NTSB, we’re a small, but mighty independent federal agency whose sole mission is to save lives. We investigate accidents, incidents, and significant crashes in all modes of transportation — aviation, commercial space, maritime, oil and gas pipelines, railroads, transit, and roadways.

You may know us from our highest profile investigations: the Alaska Airlines incident involving the Boeing 737 door plug in January of this year; the 2020 helicopter crash in Calabasas, California, that killed Kobe Bryant, his daughter, five of their friends, and the pilot; the 2023 hazmat train derailment that devastated East Palestine, Ohio; and the Dali containership’s striking of the Francis Scott Key Bridge in Baltimore, Maryland, last March, which took the lives of six construction workers on the bridge.

And one not too far from here: a series of multi-vehicle collisions that occurred this past August on I-80 near a toll plaza in Swanton Township, Ohio. Four people died; 14 others were seriously injured. 

I know from speaking with the first responders the next morning that the initial crash was just devastating for them, as it involved children. 

Amid our somber work, however, there was a ray of light: the strong relationship between our agency and Ohio State Highway Patrol and the responding fire service agencies.

Unfortunately, several tragedies had brought us together before the Swanton crashes. 

The train derailment I mentioned earlier brought us to East Palestine several times over the course of our investigation, including in the days following the derailment to collect evidence. 

We returned for our agency’s two-day investigative hearing as well as our final Board meeting. 

In between that, there was another devastating multivehicle collision that I also launched to. This one was in Etna, Ohio, just before Thanksgiving last year. 

That crash claimed six lives: three high school students in a motorcoach, as well as a teacher and two chaperones riding in an SUV. They were all enroute to a band trip. 

At every turn, the Ohio State Highway Patrol did absolutely everything in their power to assist our team on scene for these events:

  • Escorting us to the scenes and closing lanes to keep us safe;
  • Sharing their drone footage;
  • Hosting our press conferences;
  • Arranging meetings with the Governor;
  • Providing additional security and emergency medical services at our public events to keep people safe; and
  • Working with us in our investigation to help identify lessons learned and improve safety.

I could go on. 

Why am I telling you these stories?

Because the NTSB cannot carry out our vital safety mission across the country without first responders like you. 

Thank you for all you do for the NTSB. 

Law enforcement, fire, EMS. You “show up” for others every day...for the people in your community...your friends, family, colleagues, and neighbors. 

What you do to prevent crashes on our roadways and in the seconds and minutes following a crash saves lives.

The aid you provide determines how well a person recovers from the trauma, both physical and psychological. 

Your actions can mean the difference between full recovery or lasting disability. 

And it can mean life or death.

Consider the following:

  • ​Annually, paramedics respond to about 170,000 crashes; fire and rescue teams perform over 48,000 vehicle extrications. 
  • Optimal trauma care after injury can reduce the number of deaths by as much as 20%. 
  •  Forty percent (40%) of people who die in traffic crashes were alive when first responders arrived. 
  • Then there’s the untold number of people who lived because of your work to prevent crashes through consistent education and enforcement.

You really are the “last best chance” to save a life. 

Your actions also hold people accountable and spur action for safety change — to save lives so no one ever has to face such a devastating loss again. 

On good days, you all are redirecting traffic around crash scenes, putting out vehicle fires, and providing care to the injured. 

But, on the worst days? You’re knocking on doors, delivering devastating news to the families of the 1,040 people who died on Michigan’s roads last year.

Family members who’ve endured unimaginable loss. 

Mothers, like Laurel Zimmerman, whose 16-year-old daughter, Ally, died in 2010.

Fathers like Jim Freybler, whose 17-year-old son, Jacob, died in 2014. 

Laurel, Jim: I am so deeply sorry for your loss. No parent should ever have to endure all that you have. 

I’m a mom of a 16-year-old and I imagine that you’d rather be with Ally and Jacob than be here today, but know this: Your courage, your tenacity over YEARS, to fight for Michigan’s hands-free law will undoubtedly save lives. 

Like you, I have a front-row seat to the public health crisis on our roads. And it is a public health crisis.

Ninety-five percent of all transportation fatalities take place on our roads. It’s our deadliest transportation mode by far.

There are 5.9 million road crashes in the U.S. annually — tens of thousands of which are fatal; over 1,000 fatal crashes in Michigan alone each year. 

This is truly an “all-hands-on-deck” crisis. 

To show you what I mean, let me take you to Avenal, California. 

It’s about 8:00 p.m. on January 1st, 2021, an SUB occupied by only one driver is traveling south on State Route 33 in near Avenal. Route 33 is a two-lane roadway with one lane in each direction and a posted speed limit of 55 mph. 

The SUV driver had just left a New Year’s Day gathering where he had consumed alcohol, and he was driving at a speed between 88 and 98 mph. 

He swerved onto the shoulder and overcorrected, losing control of the vehicle, then crossed the centerline and hit a pickup truck head-on, killing himself, the pickup truck driver, and seven children, ranging in age from 6 to 15 years old. 

It was an unbelievable tragedy: nine people lost their lives on the first day of the year. 

We found that the SUV driver was impaired by alcohol: about two-and-a-half times the legal limit.

Driving under the influence of alcohol remains a leading cause of highway crashes. According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), in 2022, roughly one in three traffic fatalities resulted from crashes involving alcohol-impaired driving. 

That’s comparable to Michigan where 305 people died in alcohol-impaired driving crashes in 2022, up about 20% from a decade ago.

People who are impaired by alcohol often have compromised judgment and take more risks, so interventions that don’t rely on better decision-making by impaired drivers are needed. 

That’s why we’ve called on NHTSA to require that all new vehicles be equipped with passive alcohol-impairment detection systems or advanced driver monitoring systems to prevent impaired driving. Fortunately, Congress also required NHTSA to implement that technology.

To achieve to zero roadway deaths, we must think beyond the driver.

That’s the Safe System Approach. It’s not just a “buzzword.” The Safe System Approach is a holistic approach to eliminating fatalities on our roads.

It’s about designing our roads for all users – pedestrians, bicyclists, motorcyclists, and people with disabilities – not just drivers. It’s about designing our roads for safety rather than speed.

It’s about investing in transportation alternatives like rail, transit, and bicycle infrastructure.

It’s about setting safer speeds on our roads, giving local governments more control over setting those speeds (instead of a one-size-fits-all state approach), and enforcing speed limits.

The Safe System Approach is about manufacturing safer vehicles that include lifesaving technology as standard features… technology that can prevent alcohol and drug impaired driving, fatigued driving, distracted driving; lane keeping assist, blind spot awareness; and automatic emergency braking.

The Safe System Approach is about improving the safety of all road users. That includes…must include…education and enforcement. 

Enforcement of traffic laws saves lives.

It’s about improving post-crash care by ensuring responders have the training, gear, and equipment they need…and the manpower, which I’ll get to in a bit.

It’s about building in layers of redundancy so that if one layer fails, people are still protected. 

And it’s about holding everyone, at every level, accountable for safety. 

That’s the Safe System Approach. 

I read a great article some time ago. The author from Streetsblog said:

​If ending car crash deaths is our actual goal, and not just a catch phrase, we will treat collisions…as both an outrage and a tragedy — and more important, an opportunity to talk about how to build a world where, as author Jessie Singer famously put it, there are no accidents. 

The author went on to say:

We can do so much more than mourn and shrug and cast blame after people die… Instead, we can radically expand the radius of our compassion and urgently pursue lifesaving strategies outside our comfort zone. Because if we don’t, true Vision Zero will forever remain out of our reach.

If we don’t, we will never see zero.

The NTSB believes the only acceptable number of roadway fatalities is zero.

What about you? 

Who thinks we’ll never see a day with zero traffic deaths?

Every time I ask that question, no one wants to put their hand up. I understand.

Then think about a good goal. Should we aim to cut deaths on our roads by 25%? How about 50%? By when? 

Keep that goal in mind. 

Now, let me ask you: what’s an acceptable number of roadway deaths for YOUR family? 

Zero just became real, didn’t it?

There’s no acceptable amount of injury or death when it’s OUR colleague. OUR best friend. OUR partner. OUR parent. OUR son. OUR daughter. 

Three people die every day on Michigan’s roads. Three people today. Three more tomorrow. Three more the day after.

Over 40,000 people die annually on our nation’s roads. 

Globally, we’re talking 1.19 million people. That’s 3,261 people every day; 136 every hour; three every minute. 

By the time I finish this sentence in 20 seconds, one person somewhere around the globe will have died in a roadway crash. 

These aren’t numbers; they’re people. 

Mothers. Fathers. Sisters. Brothers. Husbands. Wives. Colleagues. Friends. Gone.

To end the crisis on our roads, we need everyone from:

  • ​City planners and traffic engineers;
  • Policymakers and legislators;
  • Public health professionals;
  • Police, fire, and paramedics;
  • Victim advocates;
  • Educators;
  • Manufacturers of vehicles and smart phones;
  • Insurers;
  • Rail and transit providers;
  • Fleet managers;
  • The media;
  • Federal, state, and local governments;
  • Entire communities;
  • ALL of us in this room, including me......

​​To take action now.

To radically expand the radius of our compassion and urgently pursue lifesaving strategies.

To pursue an approach that is proactive rather than reactive. 

An approach that helps road users make safer decisions. 

An approach that prevents a fatalities and serious injuries.

Yes, even when someone makes a poor decision behind the wheel. Because we’re human.

That’s how we get to zero.

And it does not happen without each of you…without first responders. 

A New York Times article from July documented the decline in traffic enforcement since the pandemic. The reasons are varied, but staffing shortages are a huge issue, especially in U.S. cities. 

According to the analysis, which looked at data from 2017 to 2022, traffic stops in declined 53% in Lansing and 35% statewide while traffic deaths rose. In Detroit alone, traffic deaths rose 5% between 2019 and 2022. 

And firefighters? The National Fire Protection Association reports that the number of career firefighters nationwide have increased over the last several decades while the volunteer fire service has decreased by 25%. 

Over that same time, the U.S. population has grown by 46% and 911 calls have increased 206% from 11.9 million calls in 1986 to 36.4 million calls in 2020. That’s more work with less manpower.

It's clear you need more resources…and we need you…those traveling on Michigan roads need you…which is why we must work together as partners to prevent tragedies and save lives. 

Thank you for your leadership, especially in the toughest of times, for your selfless service, and for your commitment to those who live, work, and travel throughout Michigan and across the United States. 

 ​


​​​​​​ ​
​
​