Remarks as prepared for deliveryNelson Mandela once said, “If you talk to a man in a language he understands, that goes to his head.
“If you talk to him in his own language, that goes to his heart.”
In 2017, I traveled with a U.S. Congressional Delegation to Europe and the Middle East.
When we landed in Jordan, we drove about 90 miles to the Za’atari refugee camp near Jordan’s border with Syria; it was about six years into the still-ongoing Syrian Civil War.
Za’atari is the world’s largest camp for Syrian refugees. It is home to around 80,000 people, down from about 120,000 in 2013.
We were there to meet with the United Nations (UN) Refugee Agency, whose mission is focused on protecting people: the rights and well-being of refugees, providing them with lifesaving assistance, like food, water, shelter, and medical care, and building a better future for every person forced to flee.
While there, a few of us met with two people who fled Syria.
Two people who unknowingly have had a tremendous impact on my life.
The first was a woman who was teaching other women in the camp how to make and sell soaps and perfume. She was helping other women support themselves and survive.
The other person I met was an 18-year-old young man who was attending engineering school in Amman, Jordan.
For some time, we sat at a table across from each other and tried to talk with one another through UN translators. But we weren’t connecting.
Then, one of the women with us asked if she could practice her Arabic and speak directly with the Syrian woman and young man.
And when she did, it was like watching a bright light go off. Their eyes widened; huge smiles came across their faces. You could see and feel tremendous joy.
It changed everything. Whatever barriers existed, dissolved instantly.
It’s difficult for me to describe, but when I think about my life, about all the beautiful moments I’ve been blessed with, this moment rises to the top.
Then...only then...did we really learn about life at the camp.
About how tough it was to live there. How people were caring for children that weren’t their own.
About the loved ones they left behind in Syria…about those who didn’t survive the journey to Jordan.
Recall, we had translators with us; our failure to connect at the outset wasn’t necessarily” a language barrier problem. The Syrian woman and young man understood us through a translator.
But we were strangers, from a Western country, sitting across a divide…a table. And we were asking deeply personal questions... questions with painful answers... through a third party. Something was lost. Something intangible.
We had failed to communicate
effectively.
Most importantly, we had failed to connect as people, as human beings.
“If you talk to a man in a language he understands, that goes to his head. If you talk to him in his own language, that goes to his heart.”
That experience changed my life forever...it’s shaped how I live, how I lead, how I communicate,
how I view safety.
It’s also why I’m determined to learn Arabic one day.
Why am I starting with a story that seemingly has nothing to do with aviation?
Because it does.
Aviation DOES know the importance of strong communication, connection, and collaboration. It applies to everything we do.
It’s embedded in SMS, the cornerstone of aviation.
In safety culture.
In an informed culture, where we are communicating… sharing safety information.
In a reporting culture, where our employees should be empowered… emboldened… to report safety concerns without fear of retaliation or blame.
In a learning culture, where we are sharing lessons learned and learning from our own mistakes.
In a just culture, where people aren’t punished for mistakes, and in a flexible culture, where we adapt to and embrace change.
Communication, connection, and collaboration is engrained in crew resource management. In how we recruit, hire, and retain a highly skilled workforce. In recurrent and refresher training.
I could go on.
I’m sharing this story because, as the closing speaker, the thing I want to leave you with is this:
Safety is about people.
Safety is about people.
That might seem like an odd thing to say at a conference focused on innovation and technology.
But it’s absolutely critical.
Let me share examples from two recent NTSB investigations.
The first took place on February 4th, 2023, at about 6:30 am.
FedEx flight 1432, a Boeing 767, is enroute from Memphis to Austin. It’s the first planned arrival at Austin that day.
Besides the Captain and First Officer, there’s one other person on board: an off-duty FedEx pilot in the jump seat.
It’s dark. There’s dense, freezing fog and visibility is about an eighth of a mile.
At 6:34 am, the crew contacts the local controller at Austin to report they’re on a CAT III approach to runway 18L.
The controller clears FedEx to land. They acknowledge.
On a CAT III approach, the crew only needs to focus on what’s going on inside the cockpit, on the instruments; they don’t need to look outside the airplane to land.
It would be unusual to do that.
They don’t even need to be able to see the runway; they can’t anyway because of low visibility.
And they can’t make out the runway lights. The First Officer can only see a “glow through the fog.”
About three minutes later, the crew lowers the landing gear to its down-and-locked position.
Two minutes pass. The FedEx crew is just about four miles from the runway when they hear:
Tower, Southwest 708. We’re short of 18L. We’re ready.
The controller clears Southwest for takeoff, adding:
Traffic 3-mile final is a heavy 767.
The Southwest crew responds:
Cleared for takeoff, 18L. Copy the traffic.
On hearing this, the FedEx Captain and First Officer look at each other.
Referring to the controller, the Captain remarks, “What’s he doing?”
He then asks the First Officer to contact the tower to confirm their clearance.
A few seconds later:
That’s affirmative: 18L, you are cleared to land. Traffic departing prior to your arrival is a 737.
The FedEx crew acknowledges; they’re two miles out. Their altitude is 650 feet above ground level and descending.
Thirty seconds later, when they’re less than a mile out on final, the FedEx crew hears the controller ask Southwest to confirm they’re “on the roll.”
Southwest replies:
Rollin’ now.
The word “now” alarms both FedEx crew, whose altitude is now just 300 feet.
The FedEx First Officer becomes increasingly concerned about the location of Southwest 708, especially because he thinks they sound “strained” on the radio.
Instinctively, he starts looking outside more frequently than he normally would on a CAT III approach.
He’s “glancing in, glancing out.”
At 150 feet, he sees “a white light that did not match the runway lighting.” It quickly morphs into a “silhouette of the left wing of the Southwest airplane.”
He immediately calls for a go-around three times.
Go around. Go around. Go around.
The Captain never hesitates. He does exactly what the First Officer calls for.
Knowing that Southwest is rolling down the runway, the FedEx First Officer radios:
Southwest abort.
Three seconds later:
FedEx is on the go.
Another three seconds pass; the separation between FedEx 1432 and Southwest 708 is just 160 feet.
That’s less than the length of the FedEx plane, which, recall, is a 767.
After another 10 seconds, the controller responds to FedEx’s “abort,” instructing Southwest to “turn right when able.”
Why? Because the controller thinks Southwest is still on the runway.
In reality, Southwest’s main gear is lifting off the runway.
The FedEx crew continues to climb, and Southwest continues to accelerate, both of which increase separation.
Also important are the actions of the Southwest First Officer to decrease the 737’s rate of climb in response to the traffic advisory — something he credits to his military training.
FedEx 1432 circles left and lands on runway 18L without further incident. Southwest 708 continues to Cancún.
Eleven days after the incident, the FedEx Captain told the NTSB he thought the First Officer “did a phenomenal job,” adding: “I'm thankful for him and I can't say enough good things about him and the job he did that day.”
I’d like to read you the First Officer’s account from the transcript of his interview:
When I said go around, go around, go around, [the Captain] didn't hesitate, he immediately did it and that’s exactly the way it's trained and talked about in all of our refresher and recurrent trainings that I've been through. And he didn't ask why until we were already climbing away from the ground. So I want to credit that, as well. So it's not just me, there were two of us there and it made a difference.
There were two of us there and it made a difference.
From our final report: “The quick reaction of the FedEx First Officer after seeing the Southwest airplane and the quick response of the FedEx Captain in performing a missed- approach avoided a potential runway collision.”
Two experienced and well-trained pilots in the cockpit on that dark, foggy February morning demonstrated the highest level of professionalism.
Their effective communication saved 131 lives: two flight crewmembers, three cabin crewmembers, and 123 passengers on Southwest flight 708; and all three FedEx pilots on flight 1432.
Safety is about people.
Fast forward to January 5, 2024, about 5:14 pm.
Alaska Airlines flight 1282, a Boeing 737, returns to Portland International Airport in Oregon after the left mid exit door plug departs the airplane, leading to a rapid decompression.
The First Officer said she heard an “explosion” and then felt, and I quote: “a whoosh of air...My body was forced forward and there was a loud bang...The flight deck door was open. I saw tubes hanging from the cabin.”
At that point, she didn't know what was wrong. Her headset flew off. The captain’s headset was nearly dislodged.
Both pilots quickly donned their oxygen masks. Noise made communication with each other and with the cabin crew extremely difficult.
The crew promptly contacted air traffic control, declared an emergency, requested a lower altitude, and were directed to descend to 10,000 feet.
Soon after, Alaska 1282 landed safely with all occupants deplaning at the gate: 2 flight crewmembers, 4 cabin crewmembers, and 171 passengers.
THAT is a testament to the flight crew, who also exhibited excellent communication, professionalism, and Crew Resource Management amid extraordinary circumstances... especially when the First Officer, quote: “Didn't know that there was a hole in the airplane until we landed.”
Safety is about people.
At the start of this conference, there was a discussion on the number of pilots in the cockpit. While the NTSB doesn’t have recommendations on that. It’s the law of the land: All commercial aircraft are required to have two pilots.
Even so, I do think it’s important to recognize that some want to change it.
A 2023 ICAO working paper summarizes it well:
Significant advances in automation and other technologies in recent years have led some in the aviation industry to suggest that reduced-crew or single-pilot operations could save money without compromising safety.
In fact, EASA is currently evaluating “extended Minimum Crew Operations.”
Think of the two close calls I just described: FedEx 1432 and Alaska 1282.
Imagine how much worse these events could’ve been — would’ve been — with just one pilot.
I don’t want to give you the wrong impression; the NTSB has a long history of embracing technology to save lives, in all modes of transportation, but technology should be used to SUPPLEMENT safety… supplement trained aviation professionals… not SUPPLANT their expertise and judgement.
A perfect example: We’ve been issuing recommendations on using technology to prevent runway incursions since 1973.
We found that the LACK of critical safety technology contributed to the near collision at Austin. Surface-detection equipment would’ve made a difference. It would’ve prevented it.
Instead, there was no redundancy to back up the controller, who couldn’t see the runway or Southwest 708 through the dense fog.
But technology DID play a huge role in averting another close call.
This one occurred on January 13, 2023, at JFK International Airport in New York.
American Airlines flight 106 and Delta Air Lines flight 1943 came within 1,400 feet of one another, endangering the lives of 308 people on board.
However, unlike Austin, JFK IS equipped with surface-detection technology...ASDE-X.
The technology prevented the JFK runway incursion from becoming an accident — an accident that would’ve had disastrous consequences.
While the FAA is no longer installing ASDE-X, we’re pleased they’re investing in new technology to improve situational awareness for air traffic controllers.
But we can’t stop there. We need more technology, more innovation, to supplement safety. And here’s why:
It took the JFK controller 5 seconds from the time he received the alert to cancel Delta’s take-off clearance.
Every second matters when it comes to safety. Every second.
And what if he didn’t act within seconds? It’s happened before.
That’s why, for 24 years, we’ve ALSO recommended that the FAA require the industry to install technology in the cockpit that DIRECTLY warns flight crews of traffic on a runway or taxiway and traffic on approach to land.
Why?
Again, to provide flight crews with redundancy... so pilots aren’t forced to rely on the controller... to look out the window in poor visibility… to “glance in, glance out.”
The NTSB is currently investigating nine runway incursions, three runway excursions, one runway collision, and one ground collision.
Last summer, we issued reports into two wrong-surface landings: one in Tulsa and one in Pittsburgh.
If we’re serious about improving runway safety, we MUST provide pilots with improved situational awareness through technology.
THAT’s redundancy, the redundancy aviation is so well-known for.
THAT’s using technology to supplement – not supplant – our people to improve safety.
Back them up, not replace them.
THAT is how commercial aviation has achieved its reputation as THE safest mode of transportation worldwide.
The global accident rate is the lowest it’s been in the past five years: 1.87 accidents per million departures.
And it’s down a LOT: about 18 percent, year over year, according to ICAO.
For that, I want to thank every IATA member in this room; this incredible safety record wouldn’t be possible without you.
It’s a collective achievement — one that’s only possible thanks to your steadfast commitment to safety.
We can and should be proud. And yet, we know safety is never “done.”
There is a phrase you’ve likely heard, or at least a version of it: The absence of a fatality or an accident doesn’t mean the presence of safety.
The absence of a fatality or an accident doesn’t mean the presence of safety.
We are here... ALL of us... to ENSURE the presence of safety.
To ensure the
presence of safety.
We are here to achieve our shared goal of ZERO.
Zero for every passenger, every crewmember, every employee.
Zero fatalities and zero injuries in commercial aviation, in all modes of transportation.
It’s interesting as the head of the NTSB to see all modes of transportation. We are known for investigation of aviation accidents and incidents, but we also investigate rail accidents, major marine casualties, oil and gas pipeline ruptures, and significant roadway crashes.
We are so siloed in each mode of transportation even though our entire transportation system connects.
If you know me, you know that my passion is roadway safety. According to the World Health Organization, 1.19 million people around the world die annually in roadway crashes. That’s 3,261 people every day; 136 every hour; 3 every minute. By the time I finish this sentence in 20 seconds, 1 person somewhere around the globe will have died in roadway crash.
Under the safe system approach, or Vision Zero, which many countries have adopted, everyone shares a responsibility for safety. That includes employers.
Zero doesn’t start once you get to work. Zero starts at home, on your travels to and from work. On company vehicles.
It is my hope that IATA members can help eliminate traffic deaths around the world and that IATA will bring this interconnectedness across all modes of transportation to the forefront and in future meetings.
Safety is about people.
Speaking of people…
Take a moment. Look around this room. IATA represents 330 airlines and millions of employees… working families… across 120 countries.
We come from different countries. We speak different languages. We are different ages. We have different cultures. Different religions. Different levels of education. Different backgrounds, experiences, opinions. Different genders.
Those differences don’t divide us. We should never let them divide us. Those differences make us stronger. We should embrace them, live them, promote them because it will make us safer.
I’m only the fourth woman to serve as NTSB Chair since the agency was established in 1967 — nearly 60 years ago.
Unfortunately, my story isn’t unique; women are underrepresented across transportation in every mode and nearly every job category.
This is especially true for roles that tend to pay more, such as upper management and highly technical positions.
Aviation is no exception.
In the U.S., just 3% of aviation organization CEOs are women. 12.6% of maintenance technicians are women. 4.6% of pilots. 11.6% of aerospace engineers. 15.6% of aviation higher education faculty. 16.7% of airport managers. 16.8% of air traffic controllers. 19.7% of dispatchers. 79.2% of flight attendants.
Globally, just 4.9% of pilots, air traffic controllers, and maintenance technicians are women, according to ICAO.
But it’s not just about attracting women to careers in aviation; it’s about retaining them.
The fact is, 59% of U.S. women consider leaving their careers in aviation. That means nearly 6 out of every 10 women.
Why?
Implicit bias discrimination.
Lack of career opportunities.
Lack of flexibility and work-life balance.
That’s what the studies show.
In the U.S.:
71% of women said they experienced sexual harassment at work or in an aviation setting.
68% of flight attendants experienced it during their flying career.
51% of women who reported it or complained about it experienced retaliation.
62% say sexual harassment remains a significant problem in the aviation industry.
And 81% of women in U.S. aviation say they’ve witnessed sexual harassment in the workplace.
In a 2018 article, the Royal Aeronautical Society said, “without an inclusive environment, there can be no guarantee of safety. Explicit and implicit gender discrimination, exclusive cultural norms, sexual harassment, and gender bias can all directly and negatively impact aviation safety. Bias can impact behaviors and decisions and undermine organizational culture. Conversely, belonging and inclusion builds trust, which is fundamental to establishing and enhancing system safety.”
In 2018, the U.S. Congress convened a working group called the Women in Aviation Advisory Board to “take a deep look at the industry, identify barriers to recruiting and retaining women, and make recommendations for change.”
Bobbi Wells of American Airlines, who many of you heard from at this conference, served on the Advisory Board.
After 2 years of tremendous work, the group issued 55 recommendations focused on change. In the words of Dr. Heather Wilson, who chaired the Advisory Board:
The biggest barrier that discourages women from entering and staying in aviation careers is culture — and it is the hardest to change. Women don’t feel like they belong. Changing culture requires consistent leadership commitment over time in thousands of large and small actions across government and industry. It’s hard work. It’s time to get started.
It is time to get started, and IATA members can make a difference. You represent 330 airlines in over 120 countries. Respectfully, in the opening and closing ceremonies, just 4 of the 20 speakers and moderators were women, including me.
It’s clear we’re falling short on culture for women in aviation.
And that means we’re falling short on safety.
As a leader, if everyone in the meeting room was the same age, had the same level of education, was the same religion, had the same background, we’d see everything the same. Diversity is how improve safety, and develop and implement the right solutions to save lives.
Safety is about people.
We need every single person here... working together toward our shared goal of safety… of zero.
Because no one should ever lose a loved one in an aviation accident or incident...no one should lose a loved one in ANY transportation accident or incident.
I think we know this. It’s the dedication, commitment, and safety leadership of everyone in this room, and of those that came before us, that has made — and continues to make — aviation what it is today.
On behalf of everyone at the NTSB, I thank you all.
I also want to thank you, Mark, Director General Walsh, and the entire IATA team for inviting me to this important event, and for your leadership, especially on safety.
Thank you.