National Air Traffic Controllers Association - Communicating for Safety

​​Remarks as prepared for delivery.
​​​

As the Chair of the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB), I obviously love the name of this annual event: Communicating for Safety. 

Of course, it’s what you do every single day as air traffic controllers. Your dedication and leadership over decades have made our airspace the safest in the world. 

The fact is, our nation’s incredible aviation safety record wouldn’t be possible without you. To every air traffic controller here today: thank you. 

I’m so grateful to join you today. Rich and Andrew, it’s truly an honor. But what I appreciate even more is what you’re doing for the National Air Traffic Controllers Association (NATCA); thank you for your steadfast leadership and commitment to safety. 

Though I do it in a very different way than all of you, communicating for safety is among my most important responsibilities as NTSB Chair. 

Advocating for our recommendations to save lives: that is why I take communicating for safety so seriously. 

Because NTSB investigative findings and recommendations can spur safety change only if we successfully advocate for their implementation. Otherwise, they’re just words on a page. 

That safety change wouldn’t occur without you, NATCA. We work with a number of Air Safety Investigators (ASI) from your union. To all NATCA ASIs: thank you for serving as subject-matter experts on our investigations. 

With me today from NTSB are Brian Soper, Lead Air Traffic Control Investigator, who many of you know, and Sarah Puro from my team.

You all know that aviation safety has been front-and-center in the national news lately. 

Unfortunately, what brought The New York Times to NATCA’s doorstep was the recent spate of close calls and near-misses involving commercial airlines. 

I’m sure many of you read the piece, which came out last month: Airline Close Calls Happen Far More Often Than Previously Known. 

One by one, the article dissects each of the many runway incursions we’ve seen over the past year: some serious, some not; some reported through NASA’s confidential reporting system, some not. 

The NTSB is currently investigating six of those events:

  • ​On January 13th, an American Airlines 777 crossed an active runway at JFK without clearance, causing a Delta 737 to abort its takeoff. The two aircraft came within 1,400 feet of each other, putting 308 lives at risk.
  • On January 23rd, a United Airlines flight crossed the same runway at Inouye International Airport in Hawaii where a Kamaka Air flight was landing. The aircraft came within 1,173 feet of each other, putting 303 lives at risk.
  • February 4th: A Southwest passenger jet and a FedEx cargo plane were less than 200 feet from colliding at Austin-Bergstrom International Airport in Texas, putting 131 people in danger.
  • February 16th in Sarasota, Florida: An Air Canada Rouge A-321 was cleared for takeoff from the same runway where an American Airlines B-737 was cleared to land. The two planes came within 3,168 feet of each other, putting at risk 372 lives.
  • February 22nd in Burbank, California: A Mesa Airlines jet initiated a go-around while a SkyWest jet was still departing the runway. The two planes came within 300 feet of each other, putting at risk 118 lives.
  • Finally, on August 11th, a Cessna business jet and a Southwest Airlines flight came close to colliding at San Diego International Airport. The planes were about 100 feet from each other. There were at least two people on board the Cessna — and 115 on the Southwest plane: five crew and 110 passengers. 

In addition to those open investigations, we just published our findings following two wrong-surface landings — one in Tulsa and one in Pittsburgh. 

We also closed our investigation into the February 27th incident at Boston Logan International Airport, where a JetBlue flight initiated a go-around after a Hop-a-Jet flight took off without clearance on an intersecting runway. The planes came within 400 feet of each other. 

Any one of these events could’ve ended in catastrophe, with lives lost. 

Alarming as they are, these events are incredibly rare. 

Of the nearly 53 million surface operations in FY 2022, there were only 16 category A and B runway incursions, which are the most serious. 

Aviation is still incredibly safe. Commercial aviation is the safest mode of transportation by far.

But the most serious surface incidents appear to be on the rise. 

I know I’m preaching to the choir. 

You’ve been sounding the alarm for a long time, calling attention to the harrowing things you’ve seen from your vantage point in the nation’s towers, TRACONS, and Centers.

This is from the Times article, referring to the NASA database: 

“’Is it going to take people dying for something to move forward?’ a controller wrote the same month after barely preventing a midair collision.”

We must listen to what you’re telling us…what the entire safety system is telling us — a system that’s been put under enormous strain following the pandemic and rapid recovery. 

And it’s telling us we must act before there’s a tragedy. 

NATCA President Rich Santa said it best: “Air traffic controllers are doing an exemplary job in a very difficult situation, but this is not sustainable.” 

He’s right.

You signed up to serve on the frontlines of aviation safety. You knew you were choosing one of the most safety-critical jobs in all of aviation. You trained and prepared for it.

But you did not sign up to miss countless birthdays, holidays, and ordinary days with family because of years of mandatory overtime. 

And when you completed the Academy in Oklahoma City, you did not sign up for the psychological stress of feeling as if the entire safety system were on your shoulders. 

If that hits home for you, please, please take advantage of NATCA’s Critical Incident Stress Management program. You can get the support you need — or recommend it to a colleague who’s struggling. 

You should never feel as if you’re the only person standing between safety and sorrow. 

It’s not all on you; it can’t be. 

The whole reason U.S. aviation has such an exemplary safety record is because we’ve built in redundancy. 

We know we need to back up every single component of the system. 

We cannot…must not…expect you to do it all. 

It’s not right. 

It’s not safe. 

The good news is that we know what we need to do:

  • ​Adequate staffing.
  • Quality training — including tower simulator training. 
  • A new contract and a regulatory framework that elevates today’s safety standards to meet tomorrow’s demands. 
  • Lifesaving technology.

Workers across aviation — pilots, mechanics, air traffic controllers, ramp agents — reported a dire need for all these things at the NTSB’s recent event on runway incursions. 

Our goal was to candidly assess what’s been done since the last time we held an event on the topic back in 2017 — and what more needs to be done. 

Representing you at that event was Bridget Singratanakul, NATCA’s Runway Safety Representative. Thank you for your essential contributions and your ongoing partnership, Bridget! 

Let’s start with staffing.

I get really worked up when someone attributes the cause of a transportation event in any mode to human error. 

When it comes to these recent, high-profile aviation incidents, mistakes by air traffic control, flight crews, or ground personnel are sometimes cited as a contributing factor.

But is it really human error when 96% of your workplaces don’t have adequate staffing? 

Only three of the nation’s 313 air traffic facilities have enough controllers to meet targets set by the FAA and NATCA. 

Is it really human error when you’ve been forced to work “rattler” shifts and six-day weeks for as long as you can remember?

The last time the NTSB issued recommendations on controller fatigue was in 2007, but what we said then is just as true today: Controller fatigue decreases aviation safety.

I’m not saying there’s no such thing as human error. We all make mistakes, have errors in judgement, and have biases that influence our decision making. Even the best-intentioned and most conscientious of us. Even the Chair of the NTSB!

It reminds me of something Dr. Nancy Leveson, an MIT professor and expert on system thinking in aviation has said: “Human error is a symptom of a system that needs to be redesigned.” 

Human error is a symptom of a system that needs to be redesigned. 

Adequate staffing is undoubtedly an aviation safety issue, and not just so you can get the rest you need to be sharp. Not even because you deserve the “R&R,” which you most certainly do! 

When your team can’t withstand your absence so you can take critical training: that affects safety.

We can’t cut corners on training anywhere in aviation. To believe otherwise can be downright dangerous.

There’s another article I want to talk about, this time from The Wall Street Journal. The August 15th headline reads: More Workers Are Getting Hurt on the Tarmac. 

The article opens by talking about Courtney Edwards, a 34-year-old ramp agent working at Montgomery Regional Airport in Alabama. 

This past New Years Eve, Courtney was attending to an Embraer 170 that was parked at the gate. It had one engine running. 

While walking along the left wing, Courtney was pulled off her feet. She was ingested into the engine. 

She left behind three children. 

The NTSB is still investigating this horrific fatality, so I don’t have conclusions to share. What I can do is read a line from the article: 

“An investigation by the federal Occupational Safety and Health Administration determined that her employer’s training and procedures were at least partly responsible for her death.” 

It goes on to say that the only reason there wasn’t a second worker fatality that day was because the aircraft’s other engine was off. 

That worker is named Mariko Dean; she was Courtney’s colleague. This is what she said: 

“I was trained by somebody who didn’t know what they were doing either. I finally found out that I wasn’t learning anything that I was supposed to be learning once we met with OSHA.”

When staffing levels are at extreme lows…when training time is in jeopardy — that’s when we need every possible strategy to help back you up. 

Which leads me to technology.

Surface surveillance technology is a powerful way to boost your situational awareness.

Recall the runway incursions I mentioned earlier? 

Airport Surface Detection Equipment, or ASDE-X, alerted air traffic control of the impending collision in only three of those cases: JFK, Boston, and San Diego. 

All but two of the category A and B incursions from FY 2022 happened at airports that either didn’t have surveillance technology or where the systems weren’t operational at the time. That’s 14 out of 16, for those keeping count. 

Tom Adcock, who’ll be up here shortly, recently helped arrange for me to visit the controllers at DCA. I got to spend some time in the tower as well as the air traffic training simulator. Thank you, Tom. I learned so much in the short time I was there! 

In the tower, NATCA National Training Representative Jamaal Haltom, DCA Air Traffic Manager Tim Harman, and Josue Gonzalez from the Safety & Technical Training unit in the FAA Air Traffic Organization showed me what it’s like to communicate for safety at the most heavily utilized runway in the nation. 

In the simulator, Angela Hudson, DCA Principal Facility Representative for NATCA, showed me what was going on with and without surface surveillance technology. 

The difference was night and day. 

The NTSB has supported technology to strengthen runway safety for decades; our oldest open recommendation was issued to the FAA 23 years ago. 

And yet, today, ASDE-X is only at 35 airports. 

ASSC is at 8. 

Getting lifesaving technology at more of the nation’s airports is the goal. 

It isn’t going to be cheap. 

Less than two weeks ago, the White House announced a $26 million investment in aviation safety. The aim? Preventing more close calls and near misses. 

It’s a fantastic move at a time we need it most! 

I’m especially glad that more than a third of that money — $10 million — will expand surface surveillance technology to more of the nation’s airports.

Even so, more is needed. 

From the White House: “Without a continued investment in safety, the current standard Americans expect could be jeopardized in the future.” 

That is unacceptable, which is why we’re strenuously advocating for the FAA and NTSB reauthorization bills that are working their way through the House and Senate. 

The future of aviation safety depends on it.

On that note, we’re standing on the verge of a possible government shutdown that will affect every one of us in this room. 

A shutdown certainly would impact safety and that’s something we should all be talking about. 

In fact, it will stop ATC training at the FAA Academy in Oklahoma City for the duration of the shutdown and take time after to ramp back up.

My vision… the NTSB’s vision… for the future of aviation can be summed up in one word: Zero.

Zero aviation deaths. Zero aviation injuries. 

Zero for workers, zero for passengers, zero for everyone. 

Zero is the only acceptable number.

It’s not an easy goal. 

I spoke of our current challenges; well, we all know what’s coming: it’s the focus of the next panel.

Our airspace — already the most complex in the world — is about to get even more congested: Drones. Advanced air mobility. Even more commercial space launches and reentries. 

Add to that new fuels, including zero-emission electric and hydrogen aircraft. We’re looking at more and more lithium-ion batteries transported on cargo planes.

To maintain our gold standard of safety amid all this change…to forge an even safer future…we must increase staffing. That requires sound workforce planning, so the talent pipeline doesn’t dry up. 

We must ensure every controller has quality training and the time to dedicate to professional development. 

We must give you every tool — every technological advantage — to help you protect our skies. 

And we must elevate today’s standards to meet the demands of tomorrow! 

Thank you.                                                                                          ​



​​​​​​ ​
​
​