|
From:
|
NTSB
|
|
To:
|
PHMSA
|
|
Date:
|
3/19/2015
|
|
Response:
|
From the NTSB’s comments to Docket No. PHMSA–2013–0225 (HM–218H), Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration’s (PHMSA) notice of proposed rulemaking (NPRM), Hazardous Materials: Miscellaneous Amendments, published on January 23, 2015.
Standards for Mobile Acetylene Trailers
A 2009 NTSB Special Investigation Report discussed four accidents that occurred between July 25, 2007, and June 9, 2008, involving highway vehicles containing bulk quantities of acetylene gas, and reviewed reports of a 2008 accident of another vehicle that overturned. The vehicles, mobile acetylene trailers, carried up to 225 acetylene cylinders that were connected by a manifold system. The vehicles in two of the accidents overturned on public highways: in East New Orleans, Louisiana, on October 20, 2007, and in Lamar, Colorado, on June 9, 2008. Two other accidents occurred while the vehicles were being prepared for unloading: in Dallas, Texas, on July 25, 2007, and in The Woodlands, Texas, on August 7, 2007. In the two overturn accidents, cylinders were ejected from the trailers and damaged, releasing acetylene, which ignited. In one unloading accident, the fire on the initial trailer spread to cylinders on an adjacent trailer. In the other, the fire spread to cylinders on adjacent trailers and to nearby buildings and vehicles.
The failures of the cylinders on these trailers and the resultant damage raised concerns about the accident protection provided by these vehicles, the adequacy of the minimum safety standards, and procedures applicable to unloading these vehicles. The NTSB report contained two safety recommendations to PHMSA. (H-09-1 and H-09-2)
Cylinder Securement and Impact Protection
In the East New Orleans, Louisiana, accident, 32 cylinders were thrown from the vehicle, valves were broken, and the venting acetylene ignited. Postaccident examination of the cylinders also found impact marks that indicated several cylinders struck other cylinders or objects during the vehicle rollover. Given the shock sensitivity of acetylene, impacts sustained during the rollover may have provided sufficient energy to ignite acetylene within intact cylinders. Similarly, in the Lamar, Colorado, accident, about half of the cylinders were thrown from the trailer, with 86 cylinders exhibiting broken valves.
The NTSB concluded that the fires in the East New Orleans, Louisiana, and Lamar, Colorado, accidents occurred as a result of the ejection of unsecured cylinders during the rollovers of the mobile acetylene trailers. The resulting damage to many of the cylinders and valves released acetylene, which then ignited. The NTSB further concluded that the HMR covering mobile acetylene trailers did not sufficiently address (1) the protection of the cylinders, valves, and fittings on the trailers from impact forces that occur during an overturn accident and (2) the secure mounting of the cylinders to the vehicles.
PHMSA proposes in this NPRM to remedy the lack of cylinder securement and accident impact protection requirements by incorporating by reference the CGA standard G-1.6 (seventh edition [2011]). PHMSA further proposes to revise Title 49 Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) 173.301(g)(1)(iii) to require that mobile acetylene trailers be maintained, operated, and transported in accordance with CGA standard G-1.6. Further, PHMSA seeks comment on the inclusion of CGA Technical Bulletin TB-25, Design Considerations for Tube Trailers to address structural integrity.
We note that section 4 of CGA standard G-1.6 discusses mobile acetylene trailer design, and cylinder and piping arrangement. Section 4.1 shows views of typical mobile acetylene trailer system manifold piping. Section 4.2 requires the piping and tubing systems for mobile acetylene trailers to be designed, constructed, inspected, and tested in accordance with applicable requirements of the American Society of Mechanical Engineers Standard B31.3, Process Piping. The CGA standard states that “piping on an acetylene trailer shall be braced and supported to resist strain and vibration normally incident to transportation;” that “tubing and cylinder leads shall be flexible to prevent damage to valves, gauges, and fittings during transit;” and that “cylinder leads connecting cylinders to manifolds shall be designed to resist strain and vibration encountered when the trailer is in transit.” Section 4.3 includes a provision that cylinders shall be transported vertically and secured together as a unit in accordance with the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations at 49 CFR 393.102, which provides performance criteria for cargo securement devices and systems during normal transportation activities. Section 4.3 also specifies “manifolded cylinder valves shall be provided with valve protection meeting the requirements of the HMR (49 CFR Parts 100-185).” However, neither G-1.6 nor the referenced documents address accident impact protection from multidirectional forces that are likely to be encountered during highway accidents, including rollover.
Currently, 49 CFR 173.301(i) applies the requirements of CGA TB-25 only to motor vehicle framework for horizontally mounted cylinders longer than 6.5 feet in tube trailers. It does not apply to vertically mounted, manifolded cylinders on mobile acetylene trailers. If the proposed regulation applied accident damage protection provisions of CGA TB-25 to mobile acetylene trailer construction, it would require the valves, pressure relief devices, and other piping components in direct communication with the lading to be installed within the motor vehicle framework; or within a collision-resistant guard, protective device, or housing in compliance with CGA S-1.1, Pressure Relief Device Standards, Part 1, Cylinders for Compressed Gases. If applied to mobile acetylene trailers, the protective device or housing, and the manner of attachment to the vehicle structure would be designed to minimize the loss of product lading when subjected to static loading in all directions, or the overturn of the vehicle, equal to two times the loaded gross weight of the motor vehicle combination. A revision to CGA TB 25 to include vertically mounted, manifolded cylinders would provide a standard for accurate and verifiable performance testing, analytical methods, or a combination thereof, to prove the adequacy of mobile acetylene trailer designs in both normal operation and accident conditions.
Contrary to the PHMSA discussion, the proposed changes in the NPRM do not address cylinder securement, vehicle accident impact, or rollover protection as was recommended by the NTSB. Therefore, the NTSB urges PHMSA to reconsider its proposed actions addressing mobile acetylene trailer cylinder securement requirements to fully address these shortcomings in the regulations.
Operator Unloading Procedures
In the 2009 NTSB Special Investigation Report on Mobile Acetylene Trailer Accidents, the NTSB noted:
Federal regulations and CGA guidance concerning mobile acetylene trailers…are silent concerning trailer unloading procedures other than the recommendation that a trained person be in attendance during manual valve operations and when a trailer is being connected or disconnected.
[T]he procedures were not sufficient to safeguard against the initiation of a decomposition reaction within the manifold piping and cylinders when simple human errors occurred…The complexity of the unloading procedures and the extreme instability of acetylene together created situations having little or no room for human error…[T]he current acetylene unloading procedures by themselves are not adequate to ensure safety…PHMSA should require fail-safe equipment that ensures that operators of mobile acetylene trailers can perform unloading procedures only correctly and in [the proper] sequence.
The NTSB is pleased that CGA standard G-1.6, seventh edition, provides basic minimum requirements for operator training, and the PHMSA proposal to adopt this
|
|
