Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content
Bookmark and Share this page

Accident Report Detail

Automobile Crash off the Silliman Evans Bridge, I-24/65

Executive Summary

​Shortly before 5:45 a.m., on July 27, 1973 in a light ground fog or haze, a car crashed through the barrier system on the edge of the Silliman Evans Bridge, I-24/65, in Nashville, Tenn. There were nine persons in the automobile; seven passengers and the driver died. None of the occupants were ejected.

The automobile was traveling on the off-ramp from eastbound I-40 onto northbound I-24/65. When it reached the vicinity of the juncture of the two roadways, the car deviated from the pathway provided and struck the curb face of a raised concrete island. Impact with the island caused the driver to lose control of the automobile, which then traveled northeast across the two lanes of I-24/65 and struck and displaced a boxbeam guardrail located on a concrete curb in front of the bridge rail. As the right front wheel of the car struck and mounted the curb, the automobile moved forward with dynamic uplift, overrode the box-beam, plunged through the bridge rail, and fell 65 feet to the ground.

The pavement on the bridge was dry. There was no evidence of excessive speed, and no other traffic was present at the time of the crash. Alcohol was not involved.

The following are contributing factors which may have confused the driver: (a) increasing curvature of the ramp; (b) narrowing of the ramp from two lanes to one; (c) a misleading traffic-control sign; (d) misleading pavement markings; and (e) an inadequately delineated and unnecessary section of a concrete island which narrowed the pathway to less than the width of a normal traffic lane--all in the last 600 feet of the ramp.

This confusion probably contributed to the striking of the concrete island, which caused loss of control of the automobile and its subsequent impact with the bridge rail barrier system.

The fall of the automobile to the ground and the resultant fatalities were caused by the failure of the barrier systems to retain or redirect the errant vehicle. Contributing to this failure were: (a) an unnecessary 9-inch-high curb, which provided the impacting vehicle with dynamic uplift; (b) improper installation of a box-beam median-type barrier system rather than a more rigid system; (c) redesign of the boxbeam mounting method, which did not secure the beam to its base; (d) inadequate maintenance of the box-beam; and (e) an outside bridge rail not adequate to withstand the vehicle impact.

The probable cause of the failure to detect and correct these hazards was the absence of a systematic program for the identification, surveillance, and correction of potential, or existing, hazardous conditions on the highway.

Probable Cause

​The National Transportation Safety Board determines that the probable cause of this accident was the failure of the driver to maintain her vehicle in the pathway provided.

Accident Location: Nashville , TN    
Accident Date: 7/27/1973
Accident ID: 80368

Date Adopted: 6/13/1974
NTSB Number: HAR-74-02
NTIS Number: PB-234406/AS

Related Report

Related Press Releases

Related Events

Related Investigations